Peloton vs. MYX Fitness Bike: Complete Comparison & Tips

GirlBikeLove is supported by its users. Hence, some of the links in this post are affiliate links. This means if you click on the link and purchase the item, we will receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. All opinions remain our own.

By Katie Pierson, Certified Spinning® Instructor

The pandemic reshaped the fitness industry when gyms all over the world were closed. Many people purchased a Peloton bike, and it arguably became the most popular at-home cycling solution with few competitors. But with over 50% of former gym members claiming they will not be returning after all gyms reopen, a considerable opportunity awaits cycling manufacturers. One bike, in particular, the MYX Fitness Bike, might be able to battle Peloton for the crown. Join us as we explore why the MYX Fitness Bike is a worthy opponent.

peloton vs myx fitness bike

Key Differences

Although both the Peloton and the MYX Fitness Bike offer an exceptional riding experience, a few significant differences may persuade potential buyers. The chart below clarifies a few of the key differences discussed in greater detail later in this article. 

FeaturesPelotonMYX
Resistance Type & Levels100 levels of magnetic resistanceFriction
Drive SystemBeltBelt
Flywheel Weight30 pounds41 pounds
PedalsLook Delta SPD & Toe Cages
Screen Size22”21.5”
Live ClassesYesNo
Monthly Membership Costs$39$29
Equipment Price$1895$1199
Max User Height/Weight6’5”/297 pounds6’8”/350 pounds
Key Differences of Peloton & MYX Bikes

The Peloton at a Glance

Peloton Bike Peloton Bike
4.7

Maybe the most popular indoor cycle, and for a good reason. Excellent quality with an excellent app for beginners and experts. The only downside it that users cannot change resistance when using apps like Zwift etc.

Peloton Main Features

  • Integrated app into the bike
  • Flywheel weight: 30 pounds
  • HD Touchscreen
  • Peloton application
  • Magnetic resistance with 100 micro-adjustable resistance levels
  • 3-pound hand-weights included
  • Dual water bottle holder
  • 4-way seat adjustability
  • 2-way handlebar adjustability

The high-tech Peloton bike is one of the most popular bikes on the market due to the bike’s quality construction and the magnetizing Peloton community. After a recent price reduction due to the introduction of Peloton’s newest model, this bike retails for $1895. The thirty-pound flywheel smoothly rotates with a belt drive system. This cycle includes 100 levels of magnetic resistance that can challenge riders of all levels.

The Peloton bike touts a 4.8 out of 5 consumer rating. Many reviewers commented about the quality construction that this model offers. Reviewers included statements such as “well made” and “responsive to all body types and sizes.” The vast majority of reviewers discussed the captivating team of Elite Peloton instructors and inspiring workouts available for only $39 per month. Over 5,000 classes are available On Demand, and up to fourteen live classes take place daily, which are easy to view upon the 22” HD touchscreen included with the purchase. This bike is fully integrated into this brand’s technology, allowing riders access to the interactive leaderboard that delivers real-time stats during any class. As of the second quarter of 2021, Peloton has over 4.4 million members in their Peloton Community.

Peloton Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Inspiring Peloton community
  • 22” touchscreen included
  • Interactive Leaderboard
  • 5-year warranty

Cons

  • Only 2-way handlebar adjustability
  • Requires specific Look Delta clips instead of standard SPD
  • More expensive than similar models
  • Wi-Fi required
  • Touchscreen does not rotate

The MYX Fitness Bike at a Glance

MYX Fitness Bike MYX Fitness Bike
4.8

One of the most exciting features is how this bike focuses on heart rate zone training. You don't only receive a heart rate monitor, but also personalized heart rate zones to help you reach your specific goals.

MYX Main Features

  • Professional-quality bike. Used in elite cycling studios and gyms around the globe.
  • Total fitness system for body and mind
  • Interactive touchscreen tablet (21.5”)
  • Stationary Star Trac Bike (stabilizing mat not included)
  • Polar OH1 Heart Rate Monitor
  • Motivating world-class coaches on demand
  • MYX Membership (separate at $29/mo + tax)
  • Hundreds of workouts with new sessions added weekly

This belt-driven bike offers convenience, quality, and affordability. The steel frame accommodates riders that weigh up to 350 pounds and between 4’11” and 6’8” in height. This cycle can serve a broader range of riders than most bikes on the market with the extended user height and weight ranges. The MYX offers a forty-one-pound flywheel and friction resistance. The pedals for this bike include toe cages and SPD clips allowing riders to ride in their regular street shoes or invest in a standard cleat.

One of the most exciting features of this bike option is how this product focuses on heart rate zone training. Not only do purchasers receive a heart rate monitor, but buyers also receive personalized heart rate zones to help them reach their specific goals. It is no wonder why this bike rated a 4.5 out of 5 with consumers. Buyers boasted about the fast delivery time, including “arrived in two weeks compared to Peloton’s two-month delivery window.” Many reviewers expressed how pleased they were with the bike’s craftsmanship. Also, the MYX app is available for only $29 per month and provides access to On-Demand classes, 24/7 streaming news from Newsy, and keeps track of your progress.

MYX Fitness Bike Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Affordable
  • 360 degree swiveling 21.5” touchscreen included
  • Heavier flywheel
  • Inability to max-out resistance
  • MYX App
  • Integrates with Netflix
  • 4-way adjustable handlebars

Cons

  • Does not offer live classes
  • Does not integrate with apps such as Fitbit or Swift

Detailed Comparison of Peloton & MYX

We have discussed the great qualities of each bike individually, but let’s dig in and look at these two indoor cycling options in how they compare to one another.

Resistance

The Peloton offers 100 levels of magnetic resistance. Magnetic resistance requires less maintenance, but stronger riders or elite cyclists can max out resistance levels, leaving them desiring a little more. 

The MYX Fitness Bike offers a friction resistance system. Friction resistance systems require slightly more maintenance than magnetic. The amount of friction resistance available is more significant than a bike that provides predisposed magnetic resistance levels. 

Handlebars

The ability to move handlebars up and down and front and back is a critical feature, especially if you are a shorter rider. The MYX Fitness Bike offers 4-way handlebar adjustability, therefore being able to truly accommodate the extensive height range it offers of 4’11”-6’8.” This handlebar adjustability feature is significant because it allows shorter riders to move the handlebars closer to the saddle, enabling proper riding to be maintained instead of slouching, which increases saddle soreness. Riders closer to the top of the height range will also appreciate this feature as sometimes their knees will graze the handlebars while in a standing run if the handlebars cannot move away from the saddle. Unfortunately, the Peloton does not have 4-way adjustability and instead only moves up and down. The Peloton handlebars are unable to move front to back due to the position of their touchscreen. 

Related
Best Indoor Exercise Bikes for Short Riders

Pedals

As a certified SPINNING instructor, I always recommend that my students invest in cycling shoes if they plan to cycle consistently. Cycling shoes are not only easier on joints, but they allow riders to truly get the most out of their rides because they can both push and pull during a pedal stroke.

As a certified SPINNING instructor, I always recommend that my students invest in cycling shoes if they plan to cycle consistently.

Both the MYX Fitness Bike and Peloton offer the possibility to use cycling shoes, but they are vastly different. The MYX Bike allows riders to use their standard street shoes with the included toe cages and offers an SPD clip. The SPD cleat is an industry-standard and is available for purchase from any cycling store. The Peloton pedals use a specific clip, the Look Delta. Peloton purchasers will need to buy particular shoes from Peloton for them to be compatible with the bike.

Touchscreen

Both cycle options offer a touchscreen with the purchase of the bike. The Peloton screen is slightly larger at 22” compared to 21.5” provided by the MYX Fitness Bike. The original Peloton bike that we are examining in this article does not include a rotating touchscreen but is available with the purchase of the Peloton Bike+. The MYX Fitness Bike does offer a 360-degree swiveling touchscreen.

Apps and Connectivity

The Peloton community is undeniably one of the biggest reasons purchasers select a Peloton bike. With over 5,000 classes On Demand and growing, it is no wonder why the Peloton community has 4.4 million members and believes they will reach 10 million in the near future. Unfortunately, this bike cannot connect with other apps such as Netflix but can integrate with Strava and Fitbit. It also requires a Wi-Fi connection.

The MYX Fitness Bike does offer On-Demand classes that include more than just cycle, but they do not provide live classes at this time. This bike’s unique feature is MYX Media, which allows users to catch up on the news, watch interviews with leading health experts, or take a virtual ride in a foreign country. This bike can link to apps such as Netflix and requires a Wi-Fi connection. The MYX bike integrates with Apple Health but does not with Fitbit or Strava.

Additional Peloton Alternatives 

Many new bikes are joining the market that are also viable alternatives for purchasers looking for other price points and features. Below are a few of our favorites.

Bowflex C6 / Schwinn IC4

The Bowflex C6 and Schwinn IC4, which are identical since the same manufacturer produces them, offer an incredible product for less than $1,000. They include a belt-drive system, a 40-pound flywheel, and 100 levels of magnetic resistance. They include a heart rate monitor with the purchase and have Bluetooth capability. 

Echelon EX5 & EX5-S

Available for just under $1,300, the Echelon EX5 includes a touchscreen and provides riders with an excellent riding experience. This bike is equipped with 32 levels of magnetic resistance, allowing riders to push their workouts to the limit, whether riders are taking a class from Echelon’s platform or performing a free ride. The EX5S is almost the same bike but with an included 22” HD rotating touchscreen.

Echelon EX5-S Echelon EX5-S
4.4

New and improved stabilization handles and seat post adjustments including a competition seat with 6' lever-style adjustment, and a precision resistance motor are just a few of the exciting new features you only get with the EX5-S.

NordicTrack Commercial S22i

The Nordic Track Commercial S22i is an excellent option and includes a 22” rotating touchscreen. This bike is unique because it automatically adjusts your resistance to reflect the terrain the instructor is describing during class on the Nordic Track platform iFit. This bike is priced at $1,999 and includes a one-year membership to iFit. 

Nordictrack Commercial S22i Nordictrack Commercial S22i
4.7

22 inches Interactive HD Touchscreen Display streams on-demand iFit workouts directly to your equipment and provides easy stats tracking; Adjustable display mount allows for 360-degree screen rotation.


Who Should Purchase a Peloton Bike?

Peloton offers an incredible riding experience, primarily because of its platform but at a premium price. Potential buyers should already know that cycling is an activity they enjoy, and the bike will be used often, as it is pretty expensive. Riders accustomed to spending money on monthly memberships to specialty cycling studios will find the price more palatable than others that perhaps only take classes at the gym. Also important to note, cyclists who have used magnetic resistance systems before will quickly adapt to the feeling of increasing or decreasing resistance on this bike.

If you thrive on competition, love live classes, then the Peloton and their interactive leaderboard is the right choice. The almost cult-like following of this passionate community helps to engage riders and keeps them coming back and wanting more. If you are looking to feel like part of a team, we believe this is the model for you. 

The almost cult-like following of this passionate community helps to engage riders and keeps them coming back and wanting more.

Who Should Purchase an MYX Fitness Bike?

The MYX Fitness Bike is a fantastic option for riders looking for a high-quality cycle at an affordable price. Most people are looking for a dependable piece of equipment that provides convenience and the opportunity to experience a great workout. The MYX Fitness Bike fulfills those desires by offering a quality product and fantastic entertainment options available 24/7. 

This bike will allow riders to increase their fitness level, reach goals, and have a lot of fun in the process. Riders that take classes in studios will prefer the friction resistance and heavy flywheel this bike offers. Also, cyclists of all heights will value that the handlebars move forward and back, but especially those closer to 5” or over 6” tall, allowing maximum comfort.

Riders that take classes in studios will prefer the friction resistance and heavy flywheel this bike offers.

Love the MYX Fitness Bike, but want to be part of the Peloton community? No problem! The Peloton digital app is available for only $12.95 per month but without access to the interactive leaderboard. 

Related
1. Bowflex C6 vs Peloton
2. Schwinn IC4 vs Peloton

Bottom Line

Many exceptional cycles are now available, including the MYX, that are more affordable than the Peloton without sacrificing features and functionality. If you are looking for an incredible piece of equipment at an affordable price, then we believe the MYX Fitness Bike takes the crown. But the truth is, only you will know which is the correct bike for you, so we recommend taking a test ride before purchasing.

Katie Pierson

Katie is the creator of MT Girl Fitness and has been a certified fitness professional for almost twenty years. She currently holds ten different fitness certifications, including Group Fitness, Spinning Elite, Rockstar Spinning, and Personal Training. Fitness is her passion, and she loves seeing her clients reach goals they never imagined.